|
Debt Management - How Much Debt is Too Much Debt
When you undertake loans for your higher education, you are taking on serious financial and legal liabilities.
Your indebtedness can have a critical impact on your professional and personal life for many years. However,
the debt that you assume can be managed if you are informed, disciplined, and determined. If
you practice debt
management, which is a systematic approach to controlling your debt level, repaying obligations and integrating
repayment into your overall financial plan you will be able to fulfill your professional and personal ambitions
and goals. In short, debt management requires you to look at the overall picture and how the pieces of your life
fit in with this picture.
While no standard formula can absolutely predict how much money you can borrow and still manage your
educational debt, it is crucial that you make informed decisions about what level of indebtedness you
are willing and able to assume, and how you will use and manage your loans. The level of indebtedness
each student can manage will vary depending upon his or her: lifestyle, expected starting salary and
earnings prospects.
The best way to manage your educational debt obligation is to be aware of your indebtedness, not over-borrow
and plan for the future. Student loan repayments should generally not be more than 8-15% of your income, and
it is prudent to estimate your income level following graduation and determine the maximum amount you should
borrow. By realistically and carefully planning and budgeting your income and expenses during every year of
college, graduate and professional school you will minimize the prospect of major financial problems.
Remember, you will have other needs and goals after graduation (buying a home, starting a family, starting a
business, marriage, etc.). See the Education Resource Center section on Financial Planning and Debt Management
- Mapping Your Future.
To begin to get an estimate of, "How much should you borrow?" first, review the average indebtedness levels
and ranges of recent graduates from your school and disciplines you are interested in. If you are considering
several schools obtain the data for their graduates. Recognize that these are ranges and averages only, yet
they will help you in your projections of your own borrowing. Next, estimate your anticipated total debt by
calculating your current loan amounts and projecting for your remaining years of study. Using the
Monthly Repayment
Schedule Chart find the amount of your loan level in the left hand column and then find your interest rate along the
top of the schedule. b The amount of your expected monthly payment is where the two columns intersect. For loans with
variable interest rates, estimate an average interest rate. Please note that loans with variable interest rates, monthly
payments cannot be estimated with great accuracy because the rate is adjusted annually or quarterly. Do this with each
loan and add the total for all the loans you have or expect to have at graduation to determine your total loan repayments
on a monthly basis. Finally, you should research the starting and average salaries for the specific professions discipline
you are pursuing. This information may be found in the occupational Outlook Handbook, published by the U.S. Department
of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, or from the career planning office of your school, the professional and or educational
associations of the profession or discipline. The financial aid office of your school may have information that will help you
estimate your income for the early years of employment in your chosen profession. Some financial aid offices have computer
software available to help with projections of income and loan repayments.
The following Web sites will also assist you in projecting your loan repayments and estimate your income:
EDWISE (www.edwise.org) -- EDWISE™ is an online financial planning tool developed by EDFUND and UCLA.
You can calculate how much you can afford to repay and budget your money while in college and after. It's
easy to use and provides a printed report with your financial information.
Occupational Outlook Handbook (www.bls.gov/ocohome.htm) -- Here you can
look up your job prospects and how much you can expect to earn in your future career. With your estimated monthly loan repayment schedule and estimated income, you can use the
budget worksheet
to project a monthly budget. Remember you need to plan around your "take home pay" - the amount of your monthly
pay check(s) after your employer has made the necessary payroll deductions for federal and state income taxes,
social security, and any additional deductions you authorize. A "rule of thumb" estimate of the federal and
state taxes and social security to be deducted would be 30 percent of your gross pay. If you project that you
will have a surplus of income (discretionary net income) you are in good shape. If you have a deficit, more expenses
than income, either your income must go up or your monthly expense must be reduced which may mean you should be
creative now and identify ways to reduce loan indebtedness. Refinancing your education loans with a Consolidation loan
may also be an option. Now you have an informed projection of your borrowing limits as it relates to your goals and
lifestyle.
Remember, for each calculation, choice, and perception, there are transitions, which occur over time, and
thus require a recalculation of debt threshold at different points in time.
Financial Planning & Debt Management Reminders:
-
Establish a conservative budget for your
living expenses and make every effort to live within that
budget.However a budget is not written in stone, it is dynamic but
be aware of the consequences of requiring increased amounts of
loan dollars. ·
- Eliminating luxury items form your budget
and thereby limiting your lifestyle for as long as necessary makes
more sense than running the risk of getting behind on the payments
for your educational loans and possible default. See The Education
Resource Center section on The Consequences of Loan Default for a
discussion of the consequences of being delinquent in your loan
payments.
-
Share living accommodations with one or
more persons rather than living alone. This step can significantly
reduce the cost of rent and utilities.
-
Realizing that, even if you have to have
an automobile, you do not have to have a new one. A car is not an
investment it is a liability. Having a used car that is in good
condition and is, relatively speaking, not costly to operate can
make a big difference in the amount of car payments, insurance,
and operational costs. But be sure that an automobile is
absolutely necessary because it represents a major expense. One of
the major causes of student loan default is the purchase of a new
car.
-
Keep entertainment expenses as a modest part of your budget for as many years as necessary.
Suggestions for Repayment Planning
-
Early payments on principal will reduce the total interest costs over the life of the loan.
- >
Take advantage of the grace period to save money for your future loan payments.
-
Pay on time--interest is compounded daily.
-
Think before making big purchases soon after graduation.
-
Live with your new income and budget for a least a year before making any major purchases.
- >
Take advantage of financial planning programs such as your local Consumer Credit Counseling Service.
How Much Debt is Too Much
-
Excessive debt is that which alters perceptions of opportunity.
- Any debt, which influences a student's actions or choices.
-
When the amount of debt is a surprise.
-
Any debt, which results in early year cash flow crisis.
-
When the amount of debt forces you to change your goals.
-
For undergraduates, excessive debt is that debt which unnecessarily uses up allocations of subsidized loans.
-
When monthly student loan payments should exceed 8 to 10% of gross monthly income.
-
When educational borrowing exceeds the gross salary of the first job after graduation.
- >
When students over-estimate their income and thus over-estimate what they will be able to realistically afford in monthly payment, once they graduate.
-
Any debt which comes as a surprise at the time required repayment begins
For an individual student, at a specific school, with specific occupational and earnings outlooks, there most likely is a threshold beyond which debt is not manageable and is hence unreasonable. There is general agreement that as debt exceeds 15% of gross income it becomes more difficult to manage. The key to determining the exact threshold of debt manageability for a specific person is the borrower's prospect of achieving their goals while assuming their loan repayment.
Calculate How Much You Can Afford to Repay
If you manage your money carefully while you're in school, you'll be better prepared for the challenges you will face after graduation.
EDWISE™, the online financial planning guide at ( www.edwise.org), can help you take much of the guesswork out of managing money.
By plugging in projected loan amounts, estimated expenses and earnings for a future career, students can estimate how
much they can afford to repay. EDWISE™ also offers clear, concise planning information to help students calculate
efficient ways to manage their finances, along with a printout of your financial plan.
Loan Repayment Ratios Chart
| Interest Rate |
60months |
120months |
180months |
240months |
300months |
| 5% |
.01887 |
.01061 |
.00791 |
.00660 |
.00585 |
| 6% |
.01933 |
.01110 |
.00844 |
.00716 |
.00644 |
| 7% |
.01980 |
.01161 |
.00899 |
.00775 |
.00707 |
| 8% |
.02028 |
.01213 |
.00956 |
.00836 |
.00772 |
| 9% |
.02076 |
.01267 |
.01014 |
.00900 |
.00839 |
| 10% |
.02125 |
.01322 |
.01075 |
.00965 |
.00909 |
| 11% |
.02174 |
.01378 |
.01137 |
.01038 |
.00980 |
| 12% |
.02224 |
.01435 |
.01200 |
.01101 |
.01053 |
| 13% |
.02275 |
.01493 |
.01265 |
.01172 |
.01128 |
| 14% |
.02327 |
.01553 |
.01332 |
.01244 |
.01204 |
| 15% |
.02379 |
.01613 |
.01400 |
.01317 |
.01281 |
Sample Budget (Spending for Success) Worksheets
The Budget Worksheet to
Match Your Expenses to Your Income
| Estimated Annual Gross Income |
Initial |
Revised |
| Estimated Annual Net Income (Ax65%) |
$_________(A) |
$_________(A) |
| Estimated Monthly Net Income (B/12) |
$_________(B) |
$_________(B) |
| Estimated Monthly Expenses: |
$_________(C) |
$_________(C) |
| Rent/Mortgage |
$_________ |
$_________ |
| Utilities: |
|
|
|
|
Gas/Oil
|
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
|
Electric
|
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
|
Water
|
$_________ |
$_________ |
| Telephone |
$_________ |
$_________ |
| Groceries: |
|
|
|
Food |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
Household Supplies |
$_________ |
$_________ |
| Transportation: |
|
|
|
Subway/Bus |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
Gasoline |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
Car Maintenance |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
Other_________ |
$_________ |
$_________ |
| Education Loans |
$_________ |
$_________ |
| Savings |
$_________ |
$_________ |
| Credit Cards |
$_________ |
$_________ |
| Insurance: |
|
|
|
Health |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
Life |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
Auto |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
Other_________ |
$_________ |
$_________ |
| Entertainment: |
|
|
|
Meals Away from Home |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
Movies/Concerts/Theaters |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
Health Club, etc. |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
Other_________ |
$_________ |
$_________ |
| Personal: |
|
|
|
Clothes |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
Grooming (e.g. haircut) |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
Other_________ |
$_________ |
$_________ |
| Miscellaneous (specify): |
|
|
|
Relocation |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
_________ |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
_________ |
$_________ |
$_________ |
|
_________ |
$_________ |
$_________ |
| Monthly Budget |
$_________(D) |
$_________(D) |
| Total Living Budget (Dx12) |
$_________(E) |
$_________(E) |
| Annual Surplus/Deficit |
$_________(B-E) |
$_________(B-E) |
| Monthly Surplus/Deficit |
$_________(C-D) |
$_________(C-D) |
|